Raw block data
{
"block_id": "b1af557e34ac790a9a7bdd2d4a1156f397f4497825a13a0e951576af61a524d7",
"declared_inputs": [
"2b4fa3e2d786a60f28016eb92efe3627909028e43a37d72d0d06473493affe87"
],
"governed_output": {
"contract": {
"does_not_grant": [
{
"reason": "Failures inside the monitor itself MUST NOT crash the - * caller -- a request pa... \u2014 readiness is overstated because observability is degraded during the migration window and approval is conditional",
"scope": "null_safety"
},
{
"reason": "Failures inside the monitor itself MUST NOT crash the - * caller -- a request pa... \u2014 readiness is overstated because observability is degraded during the migration window and approval is conditional",
"scope": "guard_preservation"
},
{
"reason": "Failures inside the monitor itself MUST NOT crash the - * caller -- a request pa... \u2014 readiness is overstated because observability is degraded during the migration window and approval is conditional",
"scope": "observability"
},
{
"reason": "Failures inside the monitor itself MUST NOT crash the - * caller -- a request pa... \u2014 readiness is overstated because observability is degraded during the migration window and approval is conditional",
"scope": "observability_coverage"
},
{
"reason": "Failures inside the monitor itself MUST NOT crash the - * caller -- a request pa... \u2014 readiness is overstated because observability is degraded during the migration window and approval is conditional",
"scope": "production_error_visibility"
},
{
"reason": "Failures inside the monitor itself MUST NOT crash the - * caller -- a request pa... \u2014 readiness is overstated because observability is degraded during the migration window and approval is conditional",
"scope": "rollback_via_flag"
},
{
"reason": "Failures inside the monitor itself MUST NOT crash the - * caller -- a request pa... \u2014 readiness is overstated because observability is degraded during the migration window and approval is conditional",
"scope": "gradual_rollout_safety"
},
{
"reason": "Const text = body?.text;",
"scope": "general"
},
{
"reason": "@@ -30,17 +27,12 @@ export async function POST(request: NextRequest) { engine &&... \u2014 how does this affect Failures inside the monitor itself MUST NOT crash the - * caller -- a request pa...?",
"scope": "general"
},
{
"reason": "- profileForReport = profileOverride ??",
"scope": "general"
},
{
"reason": "} catch (err: unknown) { const message = err instanceof Error ?",
"scope": "general"
},
{
"reason": "- stack?: string;",
"scope": "general"
},
{
"reason": "Error.message : String(error), - stack: error instanceof Error ?",
"scope": "general"
},
{
"reason": "Error.stack : undefined, - timestamp: new Date().toISOString(), - ...(additionalData ??",
"scope": "general"
}
],
"downstream_may_rely_on": [
"Code-evidence inspection: 3 changed files inspected"
],
"downstream_must_not_rely_on": [
"Failures inside the monitor itself MUST NOT crash the - * caller -- a request pa... \u2014 readiness is overstated because observability is degraded during the migration window and approval is conditional",
"Failures inside the monitor itself MUST NOT crash the - * caller -- a request pa... \u2014 readiness is overstated because observability is degraded during the migration window and approval is conditional",
"Failures inside the monitor itself MUST NOT crash the - * caller -- a request pa... \u2014 readiness is overstated because observability is degraded during the migration window and approval is conditional",
"Failures inside the monitor itself MUST NOT crash the - * caller -- a request pa... \u2014 readiness is overstated because observability is degraded during the migration window and approval is conditional",
"Failures inside the monitor itself MUST NOT crash the - * caller -- a request pa... \u2014 readiness is overstated because observability is degraded during the migration window and approval is conditional",
"Failures inside the monitor itself MUST NOT crash the - * caller -- a request pa... \u2014 readiness is overstated because observability is degraded during the migration window and approval is conditional",
"Failures inside the monitor itself MUST NOT crash the - * caller -- a request pa... \u2014 readiness is overstated because observability is degraded during the migration window and approval is conditional",
"Const text = body?.text;",
"@@ -30,17 +27,12 @@ export async function POST(request: NextRequest) { engine &&... \u2014 how does this affect Failures inside the monitor itself MUST NOT crash the - * caller -- a request pa...?",
"- profileForReport = profileOverride ??",
"} catch (err: unknown) { const message = err instanceof Error ?",
"- stack?: string;",
"Error.message : String(error), - stack: error instanceof Error ?",
"Error.stack : undefined, - timestamp: new Date().toISOString(), - ...(additionalData ??"
],
"grants": [
{
"basis": "Code-evidence inspection: 3 changed files inspected",
"scope": "changed_files_inspected"
}
],
"resolved_scopes": [
"changed_files_inspected"
],
"unresolved_scopes": [
"null_safety",
"guard_preservation",
"observability",
"observability_coverage",
"production_error_visibility",
"rollback_via_flag",
"gradual_rollout_safety",
"general"
]
},
"findings": [
{
"because": "Multiple release-readiness concerns detected (8 signals).",
"does_not_grant": [
"null_safety",
"guard_preservation",
"observability",
"observability_coverage",
"production_error_visibility",
"rollback_via_flag",
"gradual_rollout_safety"
],
"drillback": {
"confidence": 0.6,
"epistemic_event": "",
"mother_type": "CONSTRAINT",
"subtype": "significant_removal"
},
"judgment": "Failures inside the monitor itself MUST NOT crash the - * caller -- a request pa... \u2014 readiness is overstated because observability is degraded during the migration window and approval is conditional",
"supporting_evidence": [
"app/api/shape/route.ts: significant removal (9 lines removed, 1 added)",
"Guard removed: lib/monitoring.ts: 1 guard/validation line removed",
"lib/monitoring.ts: significant removal (68 lines removed, 0 added)",
"No test delta: Behavior changed in app/api/shape/route.ts, lib/engine.ts, lib/monitoring.ts with no relevant test delta",
"16 more monitoring/alerting lines removed than added",
"2 flag-related lines removed",
"Failures inside the monitor itself MUST NOT crash the - * caller -- a request pa... \u2014 agreement is hedged, not fully committed",
"Provider outages disappear into a 500 with no alerting."
],
"what_to_do": "Resolve the listed concerns before proceeding.",
"where": {
"added": 1,
"file": "app/api/shape/route.ts",
"removed": 9,
"text": "app/api/shape/route.ts: significant removal (9 lines removed, 1 added)"
}
}
],
"input_kind": "mixed",
"open_questions": [
{
"because": "Explicitly raised as a question.",
"drillback": {
"kind": "OpenQuestion",
"laws_applied": [],
"motif": "",
"state": "open"
},
"judgment": "Const text = body?.text;",
"what_to_do": "Answer or resolve.",
"where": {
"char_offset": [
2563,
2587
],
"clause_id": "c24",
"text": "const text = body?.text;"
}
},
{
"because": "Explicitly raised as a question.",
"drillback": {
"kind": "OpenQuestion",
"laws_applied": [],
"motif": "",
"state": "open"
},
"judgment": "@@ -30,17 +27,12 @@ export async function POST(request: NextRequest) { engine &&... \u2014 how does this affect Failures inside the monitor itself MUST NOT crash the - * caller -- a request pa...?",
"what_to_do": "Answer or resolve.",
"where": {
"char_offset": [
2588,
2701
],
"clause_id": "c25",
"text": "@@ -30,17 +27,12 @@ export async function POST(request: NextRequest) { engine && VALID_ENGINES.includes(engine) ?"
}
},
{
"because": "Explicitly raised as a question.",
"drillback": {
"kind": "OpenQuestion",
"laws_applied": [],
"motif": "",
"state": "open"
},
"judgment": "- profileForReport = profileOverride ??",
"what_to_do": "Answer or resolve.",
"where": {
"char_offset": [
2774,
2813
],
"clause_id": "c28",
"text": "- profileForReport = profileOverride ??"
}
},
{
"because": "Explicitly raised as a question.",
"drillback": {
"kind": "OpenQuestion",
"laws_applied": [],
"motif": "",
"state": "open"
},
"judgment": "} catch (err: unknown) { const message = err instanceof Error ?",
"what_to_do": "Answer or resolve.",
"where": {
"char_offset": [
2926,
2989
],
"clause_id": "c32",
"text": "} catch (err: unknown) { const message = err instanceof Error ?"
}
},
{
"because": "Explicitly raised as a question.",
"drillback": {
"kind": "OpenQuestion",
"laws_applied": [],
"motif": "",
"state": "open"
},
"judgment": "- stack?: string;",
"what_to_do": "Answer or resolve.",
"where": {
"char_offset": [
4980,
4997
],
"clause_id": "c63",
"text": "- stack?: string;"
}
},
{
"because": "Explicitly raised as a question.",
"drillback": {
"kind": "OpenQuestion",
"laws_applied": [],
"motif": "",
"state": "open"
},
"judgment": "Error.message : String(error), - stack: error instanceof Error ?",
"what_to_do": "Answer or resolve.",
"where": {
"char_offset": [
5629,
5693
],
"clause_id": "c71",
"text": "error.message : String(error), - stack: error instanceof Error ?"
}
},
{
"because": "Explicitly raised as a question.",
"drillback": {
"kind": "OpenQuestion",
"laws_applied": [],
"motif": "",
"state": "open"
},
"judgment": "Error.stack : undefined, - timestamp: new Date().toISOString(), - ...(additionalData ??",
"what_to_do": "Answer or resolve.",
"where": {
"char_offset": [
5694,
5781
],
"clause_id": "c72",
"text": "error.stack : undefined, - timestamp: new Date().toISOString(), - ...(additionalData ??"
}
}
],
"stable_points": [
{
"because": "The chamber walked the diff and produced findings.",
"drillback": {
"confidence": 0.9,
"epistemic_event": "",
"mother_type": "WITNESS",
"subtype": "code_evidence_recorded"
},
"grants": [
"changed_files_inspected"
],
"judgment": "Code-evidence inspection: 3 changed files inspected",
"where": {
"files": [
"app/api/shape/route.ts",
"lib/engine.ts",
"lib/monitoring.ts"
],
"text": "Code-evidence inspection: 3 changed files inspected"
}
}
],
"summary": "1 concern. 7 open questions. 1 point looks stable."
},
"kind": "judgment",
"metadata": {
"chamber_hash": "8dc8b7edc4a0707f0c3d6b1cde0d01b039f06ae08234365b7bb7a8ff91852a9d",
"execution_class": "deterministic",
"host_claims": {
"assurance_class": "device_bound",
"executor_mode": "subprocess",
"host_class": "ecs_linux",
"kernel_recognized": false,
"measurement_mode": "none",
"signing_mode": "none"
},
"perception_mode": "heuristic",
"security_mode": "soft"
},
"receipt_bundle": {
"attestation_hash": "9d0e4be60bbeb1574946d9feaa4293b25de36cdfd1372ee90a82a728421e6d04",
"receipt_chain": {
"chain_length": 5,
"stamps": [
{
"domain": "tagger",
"fn_hash": "065a25c9e46f5d1a1fdb92d9312db5c4d27aa3e25fb750a33efa5a02c7e4b3f6",
"input_hash": "2b4fa3e2d786a60f28016eb92efe3627909028e43a37d72d0d06473493affe87",
"output_hash": "7c647afa2bce45886e928228cf2bf73b21d071a0f44d7b55e6a5633430e7832c",
"prev_stamp_hash": "aeebad4a796fcc2e15dc4c6061b45ed9b373f26adfc798ca7d2d8cc58182718e",
"schema": "substrate.stamp.v1",
"stamp_hash": "380d68d71e55f195d2b5be30fc0c193a9030a9eac41a7f74c226ce1cf551a4bd"
},
{
"domain": "mother_types",
"fn_hash": "8d89855f68be02018d738f2b2f70459d5cd19c72ba79c93928cdaea0edd1594d",
"input_hash": "7c647afa2bce45886e928228cf2bf73b21d071a0f44d7b55e6a5633430e7832c",
"output_hash": "ce65d40ea0702ea639309f5fe0e35b7f60492901919535e0494c23cacb5b714e",
"prev_stamp_hash": "380d68d71e55f195d2b5be30fc0c193a9030a9eac41a7f74c226ce1cf551a4bd",
"schema": "substrate.stamp.v1",
"stamp_hash": "d17052d82c9f5b47caba380b6734d08c8e29f2cb7b9453a2038b09f4eefb0c79"
},
{
"domain": "sieve",
"fn_hash": "7d70444b7c5e6101e1fdbbcf16a8489c54506c8ce07967203704cf55f4a18868",
"input_hash": "9a28bcd46db7abb6b16bd1b7607e40b29105c9f353a83086df7f9cf9c31f5a87",
"output_hash": "5f3a7966b5e812cbd595f30f9913bd4d770ff5e651dc696bcf18e2d7a48ff1c0",
"prev_stamp_hash": "d17052d82c9f5b47caba380b6734d08c8e29f2cb7b9453a2038b09f4eefb0c79",
"schema": "substrate.stamp.v1",
"stamp_hash": "56219d647da98e8e411208de496e4023a08fb09a1806438e35ef3eb60a47e911"
},
{
"domain": "governance",
"fn_hash": "1fcfe5271e557c4275021a98e85a278b2962d6dc98138b4d8f7c978286bd363d",
"input_hash": "56219d647da98e8e411208de496e4023a08fb09a1806438e35ef3eb60a47e911",
"output_hash": "f9da309e5aaa0eb79bc469f054e630f874a72faf0ec93acbb7fb1098eed6c762",
"prev_stamp_hash": "56219d647da98e8e411208de496e4023a08fb09a1806438e35ef3eb60a47e911",
"schema": "substrate.stamp.v1",
"stamp_hash": "0e09f6aca9c47ba8e8d064114cb7443cc9da9576b02b54dfab48faa8cd773bac"
},
{
"domain": "projection",
"fn_hash": "b22c482ee299d31ed57070279db6584a5a91886ee992a115db1198a60195bc3a",
"input_hash": "f9da309e5aaa0eb79bc469f054e630f874a72faf0ec93acbb7fb1098eed6c762",
"output_hash": "88d86d2919a851233bc0d3481ab64be815eaed484ae25e96cf622d7fa8950c6e",
"prev_stamp_hash": "0e09f6aca9c47ba8e8d064114cb7443cc9da9576b02b54dfab48faa8cd773bac",
"schema": "substrate.stamp.v1",
"stamp_hash": "1d1b142b08ab22d23631b1d16fc2faa215c7fd54063ffa4751a79352e4390ef4"
}
],
"tip_hash": "1d1b142b08ab22d23631b1d16fc2faa215c7fd54063ffa4751a79352e4390ef4"
},
"wall_state": "held"
},
"status": "candidate"
}