Not Magic

lib/submit-helper.ts: large addition (28 lines added)
Not Magic does not grant rollback for release readiness.
Source: lib/submit-helper.ts: large addition (28 lines added) — in lib/submit-helper.ts
Receipt: 5 stamps, wall held, ecs_linux, chain #129.
judgment
2 concerns. 3 open questions. 1 point looks stable.
What changed: 2 concerns, 3 open questions, 1 stable
5 stamps · wall held · ecs_linux

What this relies on

What raw work entered?
1 declared input
Show
0bf132c09a4a3f2bd6e98590...
What produced this?
chamber 1f42c117333f...
Show
Perception: heuristic
Execution: deterministic
Chamber: 1f42c117333f6f985b0ed658...
Did the run bind input to output?
5 stamps, wall held
Show
1tagger37a54cfbc964...
2mother_types4ea3c6a94d3e...
3sieve164db56ef77b...
4governancea0ee71221923...
5projection9d03c876b525...
tip: 9d03c876b525e59e4b43...
What admitted or rejected it?
check chain entry for gate provenance
Show
Gate provenance is recorded in the chain entry, not in the block itself. View history
What was resolved or left open?
3 unresolved scopes, 1 resolved
Show
Does not grant
generaltestingrollback
Grants
changed files inspected
Open questions
Rollback and operational readiness: + const data = (await res.json()) as { state?: string;
+ +const API_URL = process.env.SHAPE_API_URL ??
Block_id?: string };
What custody boundary touched it?
ecs_linux, signing: none
Show
Host: ecs_linux
Local signing: none
Assurance: device_bound
No device signature attached
Where is this in order?
block 3513ae634ae8...
Show
block_id: 3513ae634ae8e34dccda03224270793d404c80442a7355dd2cfe401b6f7ef964
View full history →
Raw block data
{
  "block_id": "3513ae634ae8e34dccda03224270793d404c80442a7355dd2cfe401b6f7ef964",
  "declared_inputs": [
    "0bf132c09a4a3f2bd6e985902de8cff9dfa278efd5516d92c1c2bbbbf6412ca2"
  ],
  "governed_output": {
    "contract": {
      "does_not_grant": [
        {
          "reason": "lib/submit-helper.ts: large addition (28 lines added)",
          "scope": "general"
        },
        {
          "reason": "No test delta: Behavior changed in lib/submit-helper.ts with no relevant test delta",
          "scope": "testing"
        },
        {
          "reason": "Rollback and operational readiness: + const data = (await res.json()) as { state?: string;",
          "scope": "rollback"
        },
        {
          "reason": "+ +const API_URL = process.env.SHAPE_API_URL ??",
          "scope": "general"
        },
        {
          "reason": "Block_id?: string };",
          "scope": "general"
        }
      ],
      "downstream_may_rely_on": [
        "Code-evidence inspection: 1 changed file inspected"
      ],
      "downstream_must_not_rely_on": [
        "lib/submit-helper.ts: large addition (28 lines added)",
        "No test delta: Behavior changed in lib/submit-helper.ts with no relevant test delta",
        "Rollback and operational readiness: + const data = (await res.json()) as { state?: string;",
        "+ +const API_URL = process.env.SHAPE_API_URL ??",
        "Block_id?: string };"
      ],
      "grants": [
        {
          "basis": "Code-evidence inspection: 1 changed file inspected",
          "scope": "changed_files_inspected"
        }
      ],
      "resolved_scopes": [
        "changed_files_inspected"
      ],
      "unresolved_scopes": [
        "general",
        "testing",
        "rollback"
      ]
    },
    "findings": [
      {
        "because": "Diff structural signal: large addition.",
        "drillback": {
          "confidence": 0.5,
          "epistemic_event": "",
          "mother_type": "UNCERTAINTY",
          "subtype": "large_addition"
        },
        "judgment": "lib/submit-helper.ts: large addition (28 lines added)",
        "what_to_do": "Review the change.",
        "where": {
          "added": 28,
          "file": "lib/submit-helper.ts",
          "removed": 0,
          "text": "lib/submit-helper.ts: large addition (28 lines added)"
        }
      },
      {
        "because": "Behavior changed but no test file was modified.",
        "drillback": {
          "confidence": 0.75,
          "epistemic_event": "",
          "mother_type": "UNCERTAINTY",
          "subtype": "test_gap"
        },
        "judgment": "No test delta: Behavior changed in lib/submit-helper.ts with no relevant test delta",
        "what_to_do": "Add or update tests.",
        "where": {
          "files": [
            "lib/submit-helper.ts"
          ],
          "text": "Behavior changed in lib/submit-helper.ts with no relevant test delta"
        }
      }
    ],
    "input_kind": "mixed",
    "open_questions": [
      {
        "because": "2 related open questions grouped.",
        "drillback": {
          "kind": "OpenQuestion",
          "laws_applied": [],
          "motif": "",
          "state": "open"
        },
        "judgment": "Rollback and operational readiness: + const data = (await res.json()) as { state?: string;",
        "supporting_evidence": [
          "+ return { + ok: true, + state: data.state ??"
        ],
        "what_to_do": "Resolve before proceeding.",
        "where": {
          "char_offset": [
            1183,
            1237
          ],
          "clause_id": "c15",
          "text": "+ const data = (await res.json()) as { state?: string;"
        }
      },
      {
        "because": "Explicitly raised as a question.",
        "drillback": {
          "kind": "OpenQuestion",
          "laws_applied": [],
          "motif": "",
          "state": "open"
        },
        "judgment": "+ +const API_URL = process.env.SHAPE_API_URL ??",
        "what_to_do": "Answer or resolve.",
        "where": {
          "char_offset": [
            655,
            702
          ],
          "clause_id": "c7",
          "text": "+ +const API_URL = process.env.SHAPE_API_URL ??"
        }
      },
      {
        "because": "Explicitly raised as a question.",
        "drillback": {
          "kind": "OpenQuestion",
          "laws_applied": [],
          "motif": "",
          "state": "open"
        },
        "judgment": "Block_id?: string };",
        "what_to_do": "Answer or resolve.",
        "where": {
          "char_offset": [
            1238,
            1258
          ],
          "clause_id": "c16",
          "text": "block_id?: string };"
        }
      }
    ],
    "stable_points": [
      {
        "because": "The chamber walked the diff and produced findings.",
        "drillback": {
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "epistemic_event": "",
          "mother_type": "WITNESS",
          "subtype": "code_evidence_recorded"
        },
        "grants": [
          "changed_files_inspected"
        ],
        "judgment": "Code-evidence inspection: 1 changed file inspected",
        "where": {
          "files": [
            "lib/submit-helper.ts"
          ],
          "text": "Code-evidence inspection: 1 changed file inspected"
        }
      }
    ],
    "summary": "2 concerns. 3 open questions. 1 point looks stable."
  },
  "kind": "judgment",
  "metadata": {
    "chamber_hash": "1f42c117333f6f985b0ed6583a6c5a591ebf8be273e172f20f6d03745d9f059c",
    "execution_class": "deterministic",
    "host_claims": {
      "assurance_class": "device_bound",
      "executor_mode": "subprocess",
      "host_class": "ecs_linux",
      "kernel_recognized": false,
      "measurement_mode": "none",
      "signing_mode": "none"
    },
    "perception_mode": "heuristic",
    "security_mode": "soft"
  },
  "receipt_bundle": {
    "attestation_hash": "3964ff3b09c5a92ab2124795ac5b731a72f2a1e42eb29359f40a4b4a12853771",
    "receipt_chain": {
      "chain_length": 5,
      "stamps": [
        {
          "domain": "tagger",
          "fn_hash": "065a25c9e46f5d1a1fdb92d9312db5c4d27aa3e25fb750a33efa5a02c7e4b3f6",
          "input_hash": "0bf132c09a4a3f2bd6e985902de8cff9dfa278efd5516d92c1c2bbbbf6412ca2",
          "output_hash": "667af654933c12565575e2b72b7489bcb46363f9066fe2f00e474452da13d04c",
          "prev_stamp_hash": "aeebad4a796fcc2e15dc4c6061b45ed9b373f26adfc798ca7d2d8cc58182718e",
          "schema": "substrate.stamp.v1",
          "stamp_hash": "37a54cfbc964598346875a7d2407e0b5e453cc2d8e9e9df957a5f9d53998a52e"
        },
        {
          "domain": "mother_types",
          "fn_hash": "8d89855f68be02018d738f2b2f70459d5cd19c72ba79c93928cdaea0edd1594d",
          "input_hash": "667af654933c12565575e2b72b7489bcb46363f9066fe2f00e474452da13d04c",
          "output_hash": "16ef5d8d5bfc45da5f4b08b75b36e5b7c486b9b069f26a3e17b2d2fbb31a18f4",
          "prev_stamp_hash": "37a54cfbc964598346875a7d2407e0b5e453cc2d8e9e9df957a5f9d53998a52e",
          "schema": "substrate.stamp.v1",
          "stamp_hash": "4ea3c6a94d3ed511e34cff3e131002a48b8c8ba4d6a7210ca61ec38054833403"
        },
        {
          "domain": "sieve",
          "fn_hash": "7d70444b7c5e6101e1fdbbcf16a8489c54506c8ce07967203704cf55f4a18868",
          "input_hash": "bd4c502b0596821a23caa33e00c736a78c0f170891e1479a0ccb073246ac4ecc",
          "output_hash": "eb90209a55bc723d77cee25c7448f9002740c03389f7ab29434ca336a3f92a1e",
          "prev_stamp_hash": "4ea3c6a94d3ed511e34cff3e131002a48b8c8ba4d6a7210ca61ec38054833403",
          "schema": "substrate.stamp.v1",
          "stamp_hash": "164db56ef77b67ea141b7dbfe6c733d4d853af4be4ec28f86e68f6484c568970"
        },
        {
          "domain": "governance",
          "fn_hash": "26659baf9b00aafe787ef01beafc21c332fc5f44118df6c4d9c281bd97dfff60",
          "input_hash": "164db56ef77b67ea141b7dbfe6c733d4d853af4be4ec28f86e68f6484c568970",
          "output_hash": "61f09759207416a7787422cff622a891ded9bbf941351b21054d1a17dcd01a2c",
          "prev_stamp_hash": "164db56ef77b67ea141b7dbfe6c733d4d853af4be4ec28f86e68f6484c568970",
          "schema": "substrate.stamp.v1",
          "stamp_hash": "a0ee71221923992b8e240a5b9321081d900c6aa1c3463993220c4b06d8b1bb4c"
        },
        {
          "domain": "projection",
          "fn_hash": "b22c482ee299d31ed57070279db6584a5a91886ee992a115db1198a60195bc3a",
          "input_hash": "61f09759207416a7787422cff622a891ded9bbf941351b21054d1a17dcd01a2c",
          "output_hash": "c2738c8c5604902136228f50b4b9361bc2c050fd7caf5e1cef736bac04721865",
          "prev_stamp_hash": "a0ee71221923992b8e240a5b9321081d900c6aa1c3463993220c4b06d8b1bb4c",
          "schema": "substrate.stamp.v1",
          "stamp_hash": "9d03c876b525e59e4b4360cbe5e2bb971d02ca63097226bd21d6c2d14bedea86"
        }
      ],
      "tip_hash": "9d03c876b525e59e4b4360cbe5e2bb971d02ca63097226bd21d6c2d14bedea86"
    },
    "wall_state": "held"
  },
  "status": "candidate"
}